preload
basicPlayer

Ratings 1st Matchday

Comunio.co.uk Forum Index -> Ratings & Matchday Analysis
Author Message
klausa
Administrator
Administrator 

Joined: 15 Aug 2008
Posts: 2782
PostPosted: 14 Aug 2017 18:29   Post subject: Ratings 1st Matchday Reply with quote

AFC Bournemouth:

Ake 7
Arter 6
Begovic 6
C. Daniels 6
Fraser 6
Ibe 6
Surman 6
Ad. Smith 5
Defoe 5
S. Cook 5
Afobe 4
Francis 3
M. Pugh 3
J. King 2


Arsenal FC :

Özil 9
Giroud 8
Lacazette 8
Ramsey 8
Xhaka 8
Elneny 7
Oxlade-Chamberlain 7
Welbeck 7
Kolasinac 6
Monreal 6
Walcott 6
Bellerin 5
Holding 5
P. Cech 2


Brighton & Hove Albion:

Bruno 5
I. Brown 5
Knockaert 5
Ryan 5
Dunk 4
G. Murray 4
Groß 4
March 4
Pröpper 4
S. Duffy 3
D. Stephens 2
Hemed 2
Jam. Murphy 2
Suttner 2


Burnley FC:

Defour 8
Vokes 8
Lowton 7
Brady 6
S. Ward 6
Tarkowski 6
Cork 5
Heaton 5
Hendrick 5
Walters 5
Arfield 4
Gudmundsson 4
Mee 3


Chelsea FC:

Morata 9
Willian 7
David Luiz 6
Azpilicueta 5
Boga 5
Kante 5
M. Alonso 5
Rüdiger 5
Christensen 4
Fabregas 4
Batshuayi 2
Courtois 2
G. Cahill 1


Crystal Palace:

Loftus-Cheek 6
Tomkins 6
van Aanholt 6
Fosu-Mensah 5
Townsend 5
Dann 4
Hennessey 4
Milivojevic 4
Zaha 4
C. Benteke 3
Puncheon 3
Riedewald 3
J. Ward 1


Everton FC:

Rooney 8
Calvert-Lewin 7
A. Williams 6
Jagielka 6
Pickford 6
Baines 5
I. Gueye 5
Klaassen 5
M. Keane 5
Martina 5
Mirallas 5
Schneiderlin 5
T. Davies 5
S. Ramirez 4


Huddersfield Town:

Mooy 9
Lössl 8
Billing 7
Quaner 7
Mounie 6
Schindler 6
Da. Williams 5
Kachunga 5
Löwe 5
Zanka 5
K. Palmer 4
T. Ince 3
Tom Smith 3


Leicester City:

Vardy 7
H. Maguire 6
Mahrez 6
Amartey 5
Okazaki 5
Albrighton 4
M. James 4
Ndidi 4
Fuchs 2
Schmeichel 2
W. Morgan 2
D. Simpson 1


Liverpool FC:

Firmino 8
Salah 8
Mane 7
Arnold 6
Can 6
J. Henderson 5
Lovren 5
Wijnaldum 5
Matip 4
A. Moreno 3
Mignolet 1


Manchester City:

David Silva 8
Fernandinho 8
Otamendi 8
Stones 8
Agüero 7
K. Walker 7
Kompany 7
de Bruyne 6
Ederson 6
Danilo 5
Sane 5
Sterling 5
G. Jesus 4


Manchester United:

Mkhitaryan 10
Lukaku 9
Martial 9
Pogba 9
P. Jones 8
A. Valencia 7
Mata 7
Matic 7
Rashford 7
Blind 6
de Gea 6
Fellaini 6
Bailly 5


Newcastle United:

Dummett 6
Elliot 6
Lejeune 6
Merino 6
Ritchie 5
Lascelles 4
Mbemba 4
Atsu 3
Hayden 3
Manquillo 3
A. Perez 2
Clark 2
Gayle 2
Shelvey 1


Southampton FC:

Bertrand 8
Romeu 8
J. Stephens 7
Redmond 7
Tadic 7
C. Soares 6
St. Davis 6
Austin 5
Forster 5
Gabbiadini 5
Ward-Prowse 5
Yoshida 5
Boufal 4


Stoke City:

Butland 6
Choupo-Moting 6
Zouma 6
Allen 5
Cameron 5
Crouch 5
D. Fletcher 5
Pieters 5
Shaqiri 5
Shawcross 5
Berahino 4
Krkic 4
M. Diouf 2


Swansea City:

Fabianski 8
Fer 6
Mawson 6
Naughton 6
Britton 5
Fernandez 5
Fulton 5
T. Carroll 5
Abraham 3
J. Ayew 3
W. Routledge 3
Mart. Olsson 2


Tottenham Hotspur:

Eriksen 9
Alderweireld 7
B. Davies 7
Lloris 7
M. Dembele 7
Vertonghen 7
Alli 6
Dier 6
Son 6
Walker-Peters 6
Kane 5
Sissoko 4


Watford FC:

Britos 7
Okaka 6
Pereyra 6
A. Gray 5
Chalobah 5
Doucoure 5
Holebas 5
Janmaat 5
Richarlison 5
Femenia 3
Cleverley 2
Amrabat 1
H. Gomes 1
Kaboul 1


West Bromwich Albion:

Hegazy 8
M. Phillips 7
Foster 6
Nyom 6
R. Harper 6
Brunt 5
C. Dawson 5
Field 5
Livermore 5
McClean 5
Robson-Kanu 5
Yacob 5
J. Rodriguez 2


West Ham United:

M. Noble 5
Rice 5
Arnautovic 4
Chicharito 4
D. Sakho 4
W. Reid 4
E. Fernandes 3
Ogbonna 3
A. Ayew 2
Masuaku 2
Zabaleta 2
Hart 1
Obiang 1
Back to top View user's profile
baryma
Kreisliga
Kreisliga 

Joined: 31 Jul 2015
Posts: 4
PostPosted: 15 Aug 2017 05:59   Post subject: Reply with quote

Klausa, these are not the ratings we've got! Yours look much closer to realistic ones, but still Mounie scored 2 goals and you quote 6 points ... ? Few others are also questionable
Back to top View user's profile
Guest





PostPosted: 15 Aug 2017 08:28   Post subject: Reply with quote

Score/Points
10 12
9 10
8 8
7 6
6 4
5 2
4 0
3 -2
2 -4
1 -6
0 -8
Back to top
Andy Ch
Kreisliga
Kreisliga 

Joined: 08 Jun 2016
Posts: 4
PostPosted: 15 Aug 2017 09:07   Post subject: Reply with quote

Are you going to post these for every match day? It seems like an awful lot of superfluous work compared to last year where all the ratings were easily visible on the SofaScore website/app.

It does seem like a strange system that punishes you for actually trying to play, rather than reward you for playing well. I can see it putting a lot of people off, myself included.
Back to top View user's profile
baryma
Kreisliga
Kreisliga 

Joined: 31 Jul 2015
Posts: 4
PostPosted: 15 Aug 2017 16:27   Post subject: Reply with quote

Gary Cahill is plus 1 ??? He was sent off with direct red. I can continue with many others. Sofascore is much more realistic.
Back to top View user's profile
klausa
Administrator
Administrator 

Joined: 15 Aug 2008
Posts: 2782
PostPosted: 15 Aug 2017 22:46   Post subject: Reply with quote

Please note, these are the Sportradar ratings, not the Comunio points!

A rating 10 means 12 poitnts, a rating 1 means -6 points:

10 12 Points
9 10
8 8
7 6
6 4
5 2
4 0
3 -2
2 -4
1 -6
0 -8
Back to top View user's profile
MOF
Kreisliga
Kreisliga 

Joined: 30 May 2016
Posts: 1
PostPosted: 16 Aug 2017 15:49   Post subject: Reply with quote

Hello,

Why Amrabat got such an awful note ?
And Tommy Smith ? 3-0 away win, clean sheet and minus 6 points for him ?
I saw both matches and I think their rankings are very severe.

Best regards.
Back to top View user's profile
Display posts from previous:   
Page 1 of 1



You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group