Ratings 26th matchday

Aston Villa - Chelsea

Aston Villa:

Friedel 7
L. Young 7
A. Young 7
Milner 6
Agbonlahor 6
Knight 5
Cuéllar 5
C. Davies 5
G. Barry 5
S. Petrov 5
Heskey 5
Carew 5


Chelsea:

Terry 8
Lampard 8
Cech 7
Bosingwa 7
Alex 7
Deco 7
Ballack 7
Anelka 7
Drogba 7
Ferreira 6
Obi-Mikel 6
Kalou 6



Arsenal - Sunderland

Arsenal:

Sagna 7
Arshavin 7
Almunia 6
Touré 6
Gallas 6
Nasri 6
van Persie 6
Clichy 5
Denilson 4
Song 4
Vela 4
Bendtner 4


Sunderland:

Fülöp 8
A. Ferdinand 7
D. Collins 7
Tainio 7
McCartney 6
Ben-Haim 6
K. Richardson 6
Whitehead 6
A. Reid 6
Malbranque 5
K. Jones 4



Bolton - West Ham

Bolton:

G. Cahill 7
M. Taylor 7
K. Davies 7
Jääskeläinen 6
Steinsson 6
Samuel 6
R. Gardner 6
McCann 6
M. Davies 6
Elmander 6
Puygrenier 5


West Ham:

S. Parker 8
Ilunga 7
Tomkins 7
Collison 7
Behrami 7
Spector 6
Upson 6
Noble 6
Nsereko 6
Di Michele 6
Green 5
C. Cole 4



Middlesbrough - Wigan

Middlesbrough:

Jones 7
Huth 6
J. Hoyte 6
Wheater 6
Adam Johnson 6
J. Walker 6
Downing 6
Pogatetz 5
O'Neil 5
Digard 5
Arca 5
Aliadière 5
Afonso Alves 5
Tuncay Sanli 5


Wigan:

Amr Zaky 8
Kirkland 7
Melchiot 7
Boyce 7
Bramble 7
Maynor Figueroa 7
Cattermole 7
M. Brown 6
Watson 6
Rodallega 6
N'Zogbia 5
Olivier Kapo 5



Stoke City - Portsmouth

Stoke City:

Shawcross 5
Wilkinson 5
Higginbotham 5
Pugh 5
Diao 5
Lawrence 5
Tonge 5
Sidibe 5
J. Beattie 5
Sörensen 4
Abdoulaye Fayé 4
Amdy Fayé 4


Portsmouth:

G. Johnson 7
Kranjcar 7
Crouch 7
James 6
Hreidarsson 6
S. Campbell 6
S. Davis 6
Pennant 6
Nugent 6
Distin 5
Basinas 5



Man Utd - Blackburn

Man Utd:

Rafael Da Silva 8
Scholes 7
Kuszczak 6
J. Evans 6
Vidic 6
Cristiano Ronaldo 6
Berbatov 6
Evra 5
R. Ferdinand 5
Nani 5
Carrick 5
W. Rooney 5
Tévez 5


Blackburn:

R. Santa Cruz 8
Ooijer 7
Warnock 7
Nelsen 6
Givet 6
Dunn 6
Grella 6
Keith Andrews 6
El-Hadji Diouf 6
Paul Robinson 5
Pedersen 5



Fulham - West Brom

Fulham:

Pantsil 8
A. Hughes 8
Konchesky 8
Danny Murphy 8
Schwarzer 7
S. Davies 7
Dempsey 7
D. Etuhu 7
Zamora 7
Hangeland 6
A. Johnson 6


West Brom:

Brunt 7
J. Simpson 7
S. Carson 6
Koren 6
Valero 6
Fortune 6
Barnett 5
Paul Robinson II 5
Zuiverloon 5
Teixeira 5
Morrison 5
Méïté 4



Liverpool - Man City

Liverpool:

Benayoun 8
Kuyt 8
Reina 7
Skrtel 7
Dossena 7
Carragher 7
Arbeloa 7
Mascherano 7
Albert Riera 7
Lucas 7
Torres 7
El Zhar 7


Man City:

Given 4
M. Richards 4
Bridge 4
Zabaleta 4
Dunne 4
Onuoha 4
De Jong 4
Kompany 4
Ireland 4
Robinho 4
Bellamy 4



Newcastle - Everton

Newcastle:

Bassong 8
Harper 7
José Enrique 7
Steven Taylor 7
Coloccini 7
Butt 7
R. Taylor 6
Gutiérrez 6
Martins 6
Duff 5
Lövenkrands 5
K. Nolan 4
Ameobi 4


Everton:

Lescott 7
Howard 6
Baines 6
Yobo 6
Jagielka 6
Castillo 5
Gosling 5
P. Neville 5
Rodwell 5
Jô 5
Anichebe 5
Fellaini 4

Last edited by klausa on 24 Feb 2009 12:49; edited 1 time in total

The ratings given to Manchester City (the whole team rated with a 4 )are correct?

Last edited by Guest on 24 Feb 2009 02:16; edited 2 times in total

Hull City - Tottenham

Hull City:

M. Turner 6
A. Gardner 6
Kilbane 6
Duke 5
Ricketts 5
Zayatte 5
A. Dawson 5
Mendy 5
Garcia 5
Marney 5
Ashbee 5
Cousin 5


Tottenham:

Woodgate 8
L. King 7
Assou-Ekotto 7
Modric 7
Wilson Palacios 6
Jenas 6
Lennon 6
Keane 6
Cudicini 5
Corluka 5
Bent 4

@vcf4indp: please note, these are the ratings, not the points!

I know these are ratings, is so strange to rate every player of a team which has drawn at Anfield with a 4 (-2 points).

I have a question about the Bolton - West Ham match. Why is it that Andrew O'Brien, Fabrice Muamba, James Collins, James Tomkins and Freddie Sears did not get a rating? I cannot find a rule that would exclude them from being rated.

I have had a quick look over all the matches, and I would say that at least 20 players did not get a rating.

Just wondering why that is.

i´ve got a question in respect to the ratings... why do u take the the ratings of the readers and not the one of skysports? thanx already

j.mittag wrote:

I have a question about the Bolton - West Ham match. Why is it that Andrew O'Brien, Fabrice Muamba, James Collins, James Tomkins and Freddie Sears did not get a rating? I cannot find a rule that would exclude them from being rated.

Players get a rating, when they were at least 20 minutes in field (community-news from 8th October 2008). But Tomkins should get a rating!

j.mittag wrote:

I have a question about the Bolton - West Ham match. Why is it that Andrew O'Brien, Fabrice Muamba, James Collins, James Tomkins and Freddie Sears did not get a rating? I cannot find a rule that would exclude them from being rated. I have had a quick look over all the matches, and I would say that at least 20 players did not get a rating. Just wondering why that is.

I think these players, like Arteta or Dawson are without note, a 0

DE DONDE SACAIS LOS "RATING"????????? PORQUE DE LA PAGINA DE INTERNET DE SKY SPORTS SEGURO QUE NO

Also nun hörts aber langsam auf.

Da spielt Man City 1-1 gegen Pool an der Anfield Road und das komplette Auswärtsteam bekommt -2 Punkte.
Dieses unsägliche Your Rating müsst ihr spätestens nach so einem Müll mal überdenken. Denn durch eine solche Notenvergabe kann man jeglisches Kaderplanen vergessen. Ich verfolge intensiv was da auf skysports.com passiert.
Leider ist es ein Dauerzustand, dass die Noten der User im allgemeinen ein niedrigeres Level haben als die der Redakteure. Ab und An sogar drastisch um 2-3 Noten. Auch meine, natürlich subjektive, Sichtweise nach 90 Minuten Live geht da eindeutig Richtung Redak's.

Man braucht sich nicht informieren oder die Spiele zu schauen
Nee Leute, ich weiß ja nicht was es kostet die Noten vom Skysports-Redaktionsteam übernehmen zu können, aber so wie momentan macht es 0 Sinn.

Da geht jeglicher Spielspaß flöten und wir können hier genauso gut Münze werfen.

Gruß

Notch

Last edited by Guest on 24 Feb 2009 19:02; edited 1 time in total

en mi liga(premierlij) las puntuaciones estan mal.mi caso por ejemplo : yo he sacado 50 puntos mas o menos, y me ponen solo 18.algo esta mal.
espero respuestas.gracias

philippppp wrote:

j.mittag wrote: I have a question about the Bolton - West Ham match. Why is it that Andrew O'Brien, Fabrice Muamba, James Collins, James Tomkins and Freddie Sears did not get a rating? I cannot find a rule that would exclude them from being rated. Players get a rating, when they were at least 20 minutes in field (community-news from 8th October 2008). But Tomkins should get a rating!

Ah ok, thanks for the info that explains a lot. Maybe this should be put into the rules, just to avoid any confusion in the future?

And just out of curiosity, do they have to on the field for 20 minutes? Or do they have to be substitued in before the 71st minute? I know this is nit-picking, but the majority of matches are played with 2 minutes injury time at least

Where do you get the player ratings?¿because for example..Michael Turner in Skysports.com has 8 points not 6..

j.mittag wrote:

And just out of curiosity, do they have to on the field for 20 minutes? Or do they have to be substitued in before the 71st minute? I know this is nit-picking, but the majority of matches are played with 2 minutes injury time at least

overtime doesn't matter - players have to be substitued in before the 70th minute.

PLEASE TAKE THE RATINGS FROM SKYSPORTS.COM!!!

@wackerdins: we are not allowed to take the "our ratings" from skysports!

@danigarcia: please post only one time!

@j.mittag: sorry, Tomkins got a 7, was forgotten in the list!

@Notch: wir sind weiterhin bemüht, eine bessere Lösung zu finden! Leider ist es nicht so leicht, ein Notenmedium zu finden, dass seine Noten zur Verfügung stellt!

die bewertungen sind zur zeit öfters etwas "ungewöhnlich"...