Ratings 27th matchday

Everton - West Brom

Everton:

Howard 7
Jagielka 7
Yobo 7
Baines 7
T. Cahill 7
Saha 7
P. Neville 6
Pienaar 6
Osman 6
Hibbert 5
Gosling 5
Jô 5
Fellaini 4


West Brom:

J. Simpson 7
Koren 6
Donk 5
Morrison 5
Brunt 5
Moore 5
Fortune 5
S. Carson 4
Paul Robinson II 4
Greening 4
Valero 4
Zuiverloon 3
Méïté 3



Arsenal - Fulham

Arsenal:

Arshavin 7
Touré 6
Almunia 5
Gallas 5
Clichy 5
Sagna 5
Diaby 5
Eboué 5
Nasri 5
van Persie 5
Denilson 4
Vela 4
Bendtner 4


Fulham:

Schwarzer 7
A. Hughes 7
Hangeland 7
Danny Murphy 7
Baird 6
Konchesky 6
S. Davies 6
Dempsey 6
D. Etuhu 6
Zamora 6
A. Johnson 6
Stoor 5



Chelsea - Wigan

Chelsea:

Terry 8
Lampard 8
Cech 7
A. Cole 7
Alex 7
Mancienne 7
Obi-Mikel 7
Drogba 7
Kalou 7
Ballack 6
Anelka 6


Wigan:

Bramble 7
Kirkland 6
Cattermole 6
Olivier Kapo 6
Amr Zaky 6
Maynor Figueroa 5
Melchiot 5
Scharner 5
Boyce 5
N'Zogbia 5
M. Brown 5
Rodallega 4



Middlesbrough - Liverpool

Middlesbrough:

B. Jones 8
Wheater 8
Huth 8
O'Neil 8
Downing 8
Aliadière 8
Tuncay Sanli 8
Bates 7
J. Hoyte 7
Pogatetz 7
Arca 7
M. King 6


Liverpool:

Reina 4
Gerrard 4
Skrtel 3
Carragher 3
Aurélio 3
Hyypiä 3
Babel 3
Mascherano 3
Xabi Alonso 3
Kuyt 3
El Zhar 3
N'Gog 2

Hull City - Blackburn

Hull City:

M. Turner 6
A. Dawson 6
Duke 5
Mendy 5
Ashbee 5
Garcia 5
Fagan 5
Doyle 4
Zayatte 4
Kilbane 4
Geovanni 4
Marney 4
Barmby 3
Cousin 3


Blackburn:

Nelsen 8
J. Brown 7
Givet 7
Warnock 7
Keith Andrews 7
R. Santa Cruz 7
El-Hadji Diouf 7
Paul Robinson 5
Samba 5
Ooijer 5
Pedersen 5
Grella 5



West Ham - Man City

West Ham:

Ilunga 8
S. Parker 8
Collison 8
Tomkins 7
Upson 7
Kovac 7
C. Cole 7
Nsereko 7
Green 6
Neill 6
Behrami 6
Di Michele 6


Man City:

Onuoha 5
Bridge 5
De Jong 5
Given 4
Dunne 4
Zabaleta 4
Ireland 4
Caicedo 4
Robinho 4
Elano 3
Kompany 3
Bellamy 3



Bolton - Newcastle

Bolton:

G. Cahill 7
R. Gardner 7
M. Taylor 7
Jääskeläinen 6
Steinsson 6
A. O'Brien 6
M. Davies 6
McCann 6
K. Davies 6
Elmander 6
Samuel 5
Muamba 5


Newcastle:

José Enrique 6
Bassong 6
Gutiérrez 6
Harper 5
Coloccini 5
R. Taylor 5
Martins 5
Lövenkrands 5
Steven Taylor 4
Gérémi 4
Butt 4
Ameobi 3



Aston Villa - Stoke City

Aston Villa:

Milner 7
G. Barry 6
S. Petrov 6
Agbonlahor 6
Friedel 5
Knight 5
C. Davies 5
A. Young 5
Cuéllar 4
L. Young 4
Heskey 4


Stoke City:

Whelan 8
Simonsen 6
Shawcross 6
Higginbotham 6
Wilkinson 6
Lawrence 6
J. Beattie 6
Sidibe 6
Sörensen 5
Sonko 5
Diao 5
Amdy Fayé 5
Pugh 5
Fuller 5

I have one question. Why Chelsea's match (yesterday) is not rated by skysports? Do this people have work to do? I can't believe Niko Kranjcar has 3.1 rate and Lampard 4.5. This is amazing. Can't be possible.

I don't know why skysports hasn't rated Portsmouth-Chelsea!

The ratings are back: Portsmouth-Chelsea.

skysports published the ratings on tuesday, but it has disappeared yesterday.

Thank you!

I´m dissapointed about "your rating". Very poor. Skysports says Niko Kranjcar was the best Portsmouth's player and he has note 4, or maybe 3. Same thing about Lampard, but anyway, I know that you can't use the "our rating". I´m just a little bit upset.

we're trying to find a better solution for the new season!

You can use the two ratings ("our rating" and "your rating") and count them at 50% in an overall rating. For exemple, if skysports give one player an 8 and "your rating" is a 6, the overall would be a 7.

thanks for your feedback, but one more time: we're not allowed to use the "our ratings" for pl-manager!

I think it´s important the time you take the ratings. If you take them few minutes after the end of the match, usually the notes are high. And then, as long as you wait, the notes become very poor.

Maybe the perfect moment to take the notes is 30min after the end of each match, but anyway, it´s your choise guys.

Thanks

30min after the match is too short because at that time the variance of the ratings is too high! The longer we wait the less the variance!

Right, but if you take the notes too late, they're very poor, I think.

Nowadays, how many time do you wait to take the notes???

I think the ratings do not change much after a day!