Possible Position changes

fellaini---> S
Mata---> M
Hoilett---> S
mackie ---> S
Michu----> S
Bale---> S

Michu should keep as a midfielder. He plays the same position Dempsey used to play at Fulham's.
Mata should be midfielder, same as Hazard.
Dembélé should be relocated to the midfielder's role.

Gardner from Sunderland to Defender

Bale is midfield, not striker!!

Please when comunio will do the change position??

bigusd wrote:

Dembelé (Tottenham) ---- striker to midfielder Mata (Chelsea) ------- striker to midfielder Reither (Fulham) ----- midfielder to defender Coleman (Everton) ---- midfielder to defender I have previously been against converting Dembelé to midfielder but have now changed my mind. He's been playing central midfield for 18 months now and no longer plays as a forward. However as previously discussed on the forum, there's sometimes a fine line between a striker and an attacking midfielder/deep-lying striker/wing forward, especially in a 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1 or 4-4-1-1. For example, someone has suggested that Kevin Mirallas of Everton should be converted to a midfielder, but he's listed as a forward by his club, and plays as a wide forward. He shouldn't be changed! On the other hand, Juan Mata of Chelsea is listed by his club as a midfielder and he plays as an attacking midfielder (the strikers are Torres, Sturridge and Piazon). Same applies to Sascha Reither of Fulham and Coleman of Everton, who are listed as defenders by their clubs and both play as defenders (right backs). Other players have played out of position this season, eg Baird of Fulham often plays in midfield but he's listed as a defender, and Enrique of Liverpool has played as a midfielder, but he's still a defender. The same applies to Michu (listed as midfielder by Swansea, normally plays as a midfielder sometimes a striker), Craig Gardner (can play right back or midfield, but listed as a midfielder by Sunderland).

Brilliant

Fellaini is clearly a midfielder. If he's considered as a striker so many other should be changed too, every team has a player behind their striker. If theo walcott is also considered striker others such as bale a.johnson valencia and lennon should be changed too. This has to be fair for everybody

Emmerson Boyce (Wigan) --> Rechtes Mittelfeld

Danny Rose -> defender, left winger
Riether -> defender, right winger

Michu - striker
Mata - midfielder
Todo walcott - striker

Podolski-Midfielder

Coleman ->Defender
Riether -> Defender
Rose -> Defender
Walcott -> Striker
Dembélé -> Midfielder
Mata -> Midfielder
Baird -> Midfielder
Sterling -> Midfielder

Naismith --> Midfielder
Sinclair --> Mildfielder (http://www.mcfc.com/Players)

Ramírez -> Midfielder

DEMBELE PLAYS MIDFIELD WITH SANDRO, HE'S NOT A FORWARD, PLEASE CHANGE THIS

David Luiz has played this season, within all competitions, 24 games as a defender and only 3 as a midfielder so... why do you rate him as the latter?

Michu (Swansea City) M -> A

Juanantw13 wrote:

David Luiz has played this season, within all competitions, 24 games as a defender and only 3 as a midfielder so... why do you rate him as the latter?

So, are you f*cking fixint it? David Luiz playing again, for 25th time this season as a defender, replacing Cahill... just 3 games as a midfielder and 25 as a defender (that's, more than 8 more times in the latter than in the first) and you had the clever idea to move him into the midfielder's role... ARE YOU FIXING YOUR BIG ERROR?

@Juanantw13: thanks for your feedback! You're right, today David Luiz was lined up as defender, but the matchdays before he played in defensive midfield nearly all the time.

If he'll play more matches in defence again, we'll certainly change his position in summer again.

klausa wrote:

@Juanantw13: thanks for your feedback! You're right, today David Luiz was lined up as defender, but the matchdays before he played in defensive midfield nearly all the time. If he'll play more matches in defence again, we'll certainly change his position in summer again.

Yep, he played 3 or 4 games as defensive midfielder because Mikel's ban and injury... it's a big nonsense to move him permanently to this role when he has played more than 8 more times in defense than in the midfield. All players may be relocated for 2 or 3 games (Downing playing as a left back, Shelvey as a winger -same position Sterling has, so, striker-, Mackie as the sole striker, Bertrand as a left midfielder, Phil Jones as a defensive midfielder, Perch as a defensive midfielder,...) and anyone else has been changed...

Juanantw13 wrote:

klausa wrote: @Juanantw13: thanks for your feedback! You're right, today David Luiz was lined up as defender, but the matchdays before he played in defensive midfield nearly all the time. If he'll play more matches in defence again, we'll certainly change his position in summer again. Yep, he played 3 or 4 games as defensive midfielder because Mikel's ban and injury... it's a big nonsense to move him permanently to this role when he has played more than 8 more times in defense than in the midfield. All players may be relocated for 2 or 3 games (Downing playing as a left back, Shelvey as a winger -same position Sterling has, so, striker-, Mackie as the sole striker, Bertrand as a left midfielder, Phil Jones as a defensive midfielder, Perch as a defensive midfielder,...) and anyone else has been changed...

David Luiz playing again as a defender... why don't you just accept your BIG MISTAKE and get him back to his former position as a DEFENDER???

As I said: We'll change his position in summer if he will play in defence permanently again.

Please understand that we're changing positions only twice a season.

klausa wrote:

As I said: We'll change his position in summer if he will play in defence permanently again. Please understand that we're changing positions only twice a season.

I can get this... but you changed it a couple of weeks ago and just because he played 2 or 3 games in the midfield due to Mikel's unavailability...

Then, because you decided it suddenly and just according to a couple of performances, we've to pay for your error the whole season.

If it was a longtime decision, I could understand... but you just changed it, as said, a couple of weeks ago and just because 2 or 3 games... wouldn't have it been wiser, then, to wait till' summer and then change his position to midfielder if he had been playing there for the rest of the season instead of chaging it for a couple of games and the saying you cannot change it again to the former one despite he's playing again as a defender?

So, now we have to pay the consequences for the rest of the season for the bad decision you made?

David Luiz played in defensive midfield the last four games before the position changes, therefore we've decided to change his position.

Please understand that we won't change his position before summer. We've never changed a player's position during a season exceptionally in the short winter break.

I said it before, I say it know and I'll say it again if necessary...
YOU'RE FUCKING US UP because someone among you made the stupid decision of chaging David Luiz's position due to 3 or 4 games (and this short-term replacement was due to Obi Mikel's absence for being playing the African Cup of Nations) against 25 or 30 games playing as a defender, as he's doing today while facing Manchester City...

Why don't you just accept you made the BIGGEST MISTAKE EVER and we're paying for this?

If you had a minimum of shame, just a little bit, you'd just fix it right now and would stop stating nonsense and defending the sh*t you're defending just because you can't accept you decision was WRONG, so you were WRONG... but you seem to be too arrogant to accept that...

I bought him as a defender to make him play as a defender, as he does in the games, and now, because of you and your sh*tty decision, I can't make him play... you just fucked up everyone's-who-had-him season because you had no idea and you can't admit it now...